Mac Eyeshadow Help - 15 Must Haves!?

Out of the ones that you are considering I say go with either Rice Paper for a very nice highlight or espresso as it is a really gorgeous color that you can do a lot with. If you are not however set on these I would recommend going with Sable! It is a beautiful neutral color that can work for smoky eyes or a natural look and I think it would be great for you considering what you're looking for! Sounds like a fun batch of colors, I love Amber Lights!